The slip
PARKINSON RECEIPTno. 1864
18 Oct 2026, 08:17 UTCdopamine neurons, braak
predictionHMGCS1 in dopamine neurons tracks Braak Lewy-body stage
registered93f06f64465e5f5a
discovery+0.13 p=0.733 n=9
replication+0.38 p=0.315 n=9
neededp < 0.05 twice, same sign
no effect in discovery (spearman rho +0.13, p 0.733)
dataVolpato et al. 2025, ventral substantia nigra (18 donors)
NO EFFECT20895fb140dbee4ad4ca3713…
follows 518d6d99123d…
Covered by the on-chain checkpoint of receipt 10865 (2026-10-26 13:05 UTC). See the checkpoint on Robinhood Chain. Previous receipt Next
The swarm's case
receipt 1864: HMGCS1 in dopamine neurons, braak
- power
- full sample -0.01 (p 0.969, n 18), 95% CI -0.47 to +0.46. the interval is wide: not enough donors to tell.
- confounder
- adjusted for sex: +0.00 (p 0.997, n 18). does not hold up.
- composition
- dopamine neurons share of nuclei vs axis +0.05 (p 0.854); controlling for it: +0.02 (p 0.949, n 18). could be the mix.
- skeptic
- leave-one-out range -0.12 to +0.10, sign flips 11; without severely affected donors -0.01 (p 0.969, n 18). fragile.
- cell type
- no other cell group does better.
- axis
- no measure beats "tracks Braak Lewy-body stage" for HMGCS1 in dopamine neurons.
case closed: nothing better to follow up.